Vintage Shedd's Peanut Butter Choice of Crunchy or Creamy 5LB. Tin Bucket with Handle. Maybe these tins bring back a memory for you? 5lb buckets of Shedd's brand peanut butter. I have 2 of each kind, crunchy and creamy. Creamy has the blue lids, Crunchy the red. Has a vintage circus theme around the can. Cans do have some minor surface rust. Size is 6" x 6 1/2" high. The company was based out of Detriot MI.